Sophists

Central Problem

What is the foundation of human knowledge, moral values, and social laws once we abandon the search for cosmic principles and focus philosophical inquiry on human affairs?

Main Thesis

The Sophists shift philosophical inquiry from nature (physis) to humanity (anthropos), discovering that truth, values, and laws are relative to human perspectives, cultures, and conventions. Man becomes the “measure of all things,” and rhetoric—the art of persuasion—emerges as the essential skill for democratic citizenship. This “Greek Enlightenment” liberates reason from tradition but risks dissolving all objective standards into subjective opinion.

Historical Context

The Sophists emerged in 5th century BCE Athens during the height of Periclean democracy, when the city was flourishing after victory over the Persians. The democratic polis required new skills: participation in assemblies, public speaking, legal advocacy, and political debate. Traditional aristocratic education based on birth was inadequate; the Sophists responded by offering professional instruction in rhetoric, grammar, and argumentation for payment. They were itinerant teachers who traveled throughout Greece, exposing them to diverse customs and challenging provincial certainties. While Plato and Aristotle “demonized” them as false sages interested only in money and success, contemporary scholarship recognizes their crucial role in developing humanistic education (paideia) and critical rationality.

Philosophical Lineage

flowchart TD
    Heraclitus[Heraclitus] --> Protagoras[Protagoras]
    Parmenides[Parmenides] --> Gorgias[Gorgias]
    Empedocles[Empedocles] --> Gorgias
    Protagoras --> Relativism[Relativism]
    Gorgias --> Skepticism[Skepticism]
    Protagoras --> Rhetoric[Rhetoric]
    Gorgias --> Rhetoric
    Sophists[Sophists] --> Socrates[Socrates]
    Sophists --> Plato[Plato]
    Sophists --> ModernThought[Modern Thought]
    
    class Heraclitus,Parmenides,Empedocles,Protagoras,Gorgias,Relativism,Skepticism,Rhetoric,Socrates,Plato,ModernThought,Sophists internal-link

Key Thinkers

Thinker	Dates	Movement	Main Work	Core Concept
Protagoras	c. 490-420 BCE	Sophism	Antilogies	Homo mensura (relativism)
Gorgias	c. 485-376 BCE	Sophism	On Non-Being	Radical skepticism
Prodicus	c. 470-400 BCE	Sophism	Heracles at the Crossroads	Religion from utility
Hippias	c. 443-? BCE	Sophism	Various	Natural vs. human law
Antiphon	5th century BCE	Sophism	On Truth	Natural equality
Thrasymachus	c. 460-? BCE	Sophism	—	Justice as power
Critias	c. 460-403 BCE	Sophism	Sisyphus	Religion as politics

Key Concepts

Concept	Definition	Related to
Homo mensura	”Man is the measure of all things”—reality is as it appears to human perceivers	Protagoras, Relativism
Relativism	No absolute truth or moral principle; all beliefs relative to perspective	Phenomenism, Skepticism
Phenomenism	We know only appearances (phenomena), not things in themselves	Kant, Epistemology
Paideia	Education as comprehensive formation of the individual	Humanism, Rhetoric
Rhetoric	Art of persuasion through language	Democracy, Antilogic
Antilogic	Method of opposing one argument to another	Dialectic, Eristic
Eristic	Art of verbal combat to defeat opponents	Antilogic, Rhetoric
Physis vs. Nomos	Nature vs. law/convention distinction	Natural law, Convention
Agnosticism	Position that gods cannot be known to exist or not	Protagoras, Religion

Authors Comparison

Theme	Protagoras	Gorgias	Antiphon
Epistemology	All opinions true (for the perceiver)	All opinions false (unknowable)	Nature reveals truth
Criterion	Utility (public and private)	None; rhetoric fills the void	Natural law
On language	Expresses relative truths	Autonomous from reality	Conventional
Political stance	Pro-democratic	Neutral (technique)	Critical of conventions
On religion	Agnostic	Implicit skeptic	Natural origin
View of law	Human invention, but necessary	Instrument of power	Oppressive of nature

Influences & Connections

• Heraclitus: Influence on Protagoras’s doctrine of flux and perspectivism
• Parmenides: Gorgias’s paradoxes invert Eleatic logic
• Empedocles: Teacher of Gorgias
• Athenian Democracy: Political precondition for sophistic education
• Socrates: Shares humanistic turn but opposes relativism
• Plato: Develops dialectic against sophistic rhetoric
• Modern Philosophy: Sophists anticipate empiricism, pragmatism, linguistic philosophy

Summary Formulas

1. Protagoras’s Principle: Man = Measure of all things → Relativism + Utility as criterion
2. Gorgias’s Three Theses: Nothing exists; if it exists, it’s unknowable; if knowable, incommunicable
3. Sophistic Turn: From physis (nature) to anthropos (human) → From cosmology to politics
4. Democratic Equation: Democracy requires rhetoric; rhetoric requires education; education is paideia
5. Nature vs. Law: Natural law (unwritten, universal) ≠ Human law (written, variable)
6. Critique of Religion: Gods = Projections of utility (Prodicus) or inventions of rulers (Critias)
7. Eristic Degeneration: Antilogic → Eristic → Pure verbal combat without truth

Timeline

Year	Event
c. 490 BCE	Birth of Protagoras in Abdera
c. 485 BCE	Birth of Gorgias in Leontini
c. 470-460 BCE	Birth of Prodicus of Ceos
c. 460 BCE	Birth of Thrasymachus and Critias
461 BCE	Beginning of Periclean democracy in Athens
c. 450 BCE	Sophists begin teaching in Athens
427 BCE	Gorgias arrives in Athens as ambassador from Leontini
c. 420 BCE	Death of Protagoras (charged with impiety, exiled)
404 BCE	Fall of Athenian democracy; rule of Thirty Tyrants (including Critias)
403 BCE	Death of Critias; restoration of democracy
c. 376 BCE	Death of Gorgias (aged 109)

Notable Quotes

“Man is the measure of all things, of things that are that they are, of things that are not that they are not.” — Protagoras, Fragment 1

“Concerning the gods, I am unable to know whether they exist or do not exist, or what form they have: for there are many obstacles to knowledge—the obscurity of the matter and the shortness of human life.” — Protagoras, Fragment 4

“Nothing exists. If something exists, it cannot be known. If it can be known, it cannot be communicated.” — Gorgias, On Non-Being

“Speech is a powerful lord that with the smallest and most invisible body accomplishes most godlike works.” — Gorgias, Encomium of Helen

“By nature we are all equally made, both barbarians and Greeks.” — Antiphon, Fragment 44b

“Justice is nothing other than the advantage of the stronger.” — Thrasymachus (in Plato’s Republic)

• Shares humanistic focus but seeks objective truth
• Plato - Principal critic and source for sophistic doctrines
• Aristotle - Develops logic partly against sophistic fallacies
• Democritus - Shares theory of history as progress
• Pericles - Political leader who befriended Protagoras
• Hume - Modern skepticism echoing sophistic themes
• Kant - Phenomenism and limits of knowledge

---

---

NOTE

This summary has been created to present the key points from the source text, which was automatically extracted using LLM. Please note that the summary may contain errors. It serves as an essential starting point for study and reference purposes.